Atomica
All what-ifs
What if…?

What if the Sun vanished?

For 8 minutes and 20 seconds, you would not notice a thing.

A short dystopian story

Eight Minutes and Twenty Seconds

Hanle Observatory, Ladakh. The Sun disappeared, and for eight minutes nobody knew.

1. The Countdown Nobody Saw

At exactly noon, the Sun stopped existing. Kabir, an apprentice at the Hanle Observatory high in Ladakh, was eating Maggi outside the dome. Nothing happened. The snow peaks glittered. His shadow lay crisp on the ground.

Nothing could happen yet. The sunlight already on its way was still arriving, and so was the Sun's gravity: changes in gravity travel at the speed of light too. For 8 minutes and 20 seconds, Earth carried on curving round an empty point in space, lit by a star that was no longer there.

2. Lights Out

At 12:08:20 the day switched off. Not a sunset, no orange glow, just black. Kabir's colleague screamed. The Moon, which had been a pale half-disc in the afternoon sky, vanished too; it had only ever shone by reflected sunlight. So did Venus and Jupiter.

And at that same moment, with nothing to curve round, Earth stopped turning its corner and shot off in a straight line along its old orbit, at nearly 30 kilometres a second, into the dark.

3. The Cold

The first week was the worst. With no sunlight, average temperatures dropped below freezing within days. Plants stopped making food, and the crops in the fields went limp and then black. The government announced heat rationing: one warm room per family, powered by whatever the nuclear plants could give.

Kabir's family moved to Puga, where hot springs bubble out of the ground. Geothermal heat became the most valuable thing on Earth. People who had never thought about the planet's hot interior now built their lives around it.

4. Under the Ice

A year on, the surface was colder than Antarctica. The oceans froze over at the top, but the ice acted like a blanket and the water beneath stayed liquid for a very long time.

Kabir watched a documentary, broadcast from a deep-sea station, about the creatures around volcanic vents on the ocean floor. They had never needed sunlight. They fed on chemicals from the Earth's crust, and they didn't even know anything had happened. 'They're the lucky ones,' his sister said. Kabir wasn't sure anyone was.

The end. Now see the science that the story is built on.

See it happen

Earth orbits, held by the Sun's gravity
Time since the Sun vanished—Earth still feels the Sun?YesAverage surface temperature (rough estimate)15 °C

What would happen, step by step

0 to 8 min 20 sNothing happens

Sunlight takes about 8 minutes 20 seconds to reach us, so it keeps arriving. Changes in gravity also travel at the speed of light, so Earth keeps curving round the empty spot as if the Sun were still there.

1 of 4

The science behind it

Sunlight is old news

t = distance ÷ speed = 150,000,000 km ÷ 300,000 km/s = 500 s = 8 min 20 s

Everything you see happened in the past, because light takes time to travel. The Sun you see is about 8 minutes and 20 seconds old. If it vanished, you'd keep seeing it until the last light arrived.

Gravity has a speed limit too

Einstein's general relativity predicts that changes in gravity travel at the speed of light. In 2017 detectors picked up gravitational waves from two neutron stars colliding, and light from the same explosion arrived about two seconds later after travelling 130 million years. Gravity and light had raced at the same speed.

Why the cold comes slowly, and where life could survive

The oceans store a huge amount of heat, and ice on top slows heat loss from the water below. Earth's interior also leaks heat, but only about 0.09 watts per square metre, compared with the roughly 240 watts per square metre of sunlight Earth absorbs today. That's enough for hot springs and deep-sea vents, but not to warm the planet.

In one line: Light and gravity both travel at about 300,000 km/s. Gravitational waves detected in 2017 from colliding neutron stars arrived within seconds of the light from the same explosion, confirming that gravity changes travel at the speed of light.

More Sun facts in the Fact machine →

Think about it

If the Sun vanished, how long would it take people on Mars to notice? (Mars is about 228 million km from the Sun.)